Released: Wed, 2008/05/28
ARTROCKER RATING:

THE national: a skin, a night

In 2007 The National firmly established themselves as a solid live act and their ‘Boxer’ album was universally acclaimed as one of the year’s best. So you’d naturally assume that a documentary of the band making the record would be compulsory viewing. Not so. ‘A Skin, A Night’ is no ordinary ‘making of an album’ rockumentary. It’s far less interesting than that. Vincent Moon’s film is more concerned with finding unusual camera angles than it is on concentrating on a band making a breakthrough album.
It's all a wasted opportunity that offers little further understanding of the band...
The National are mainly seen in the recording studio, where we hear vocals being recorded, or in one sequence the camera pokes its head up from the floor between the band as they lay down handclaps. Occasionally members of the group talk to the camera about the album’s recording and the odd snippet of an interesting fact is revealed, but largely ‘A Skin, A Night’ comes over as a student project that just happens to capture a band at a vital moment in their career. It’s all a wasted opportunity that offers little further understanding of the band. Far more worthwhile in this package is the bonus Virginia EP. This 12 track disc offers live and demo versions of some of the songs that appeared on ‘Boxer’, as well as covers and radio sessions. ‘Blank Slate’ is the standout track, capable of standing alongside their best work. A radio session version of ‘Lucky You’ and the beautiful live version of ‘Fake Empire’ simply illustrate that there is much to recommend this band, even if you can’t say the same for the film.

    Post new comment

    The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

MORE STORIES ABOUT

Best of 2009

Rabbit, Rabbit All Day Long...

Latest News

  • Holy Ho-Hos Lisa Marie!

    We can't believe our eyes!!!
    This is tragic BEYOND tragic!
    The upcoming issue of The National Enquirer is sporting this shocking pic of Lisa Marie Presley out with her da...

  • Belle & Sebastian, The National, Grizzly Bear for Latitude 2010

    Belle & Sebastian, The National, Grizzly Bear for Latitude 2010

    The initial batch of headliners for this year's 2010 Latitude Festival has been announced and...it's pretty good all in all. Headlining the Obelisk Arena, which is the ma...

  • Dancing About Architecture Indie Music News 03.09.10

    Dancing About Architecture Indie Music News 03.09.10

    Mark Linkous dies, but his final album is out in the summer, also news on new albums from The National, LCD Soundsystem, Phosphorescent and Robert Pollard, live footage o...

  • New National Album: High Violet

    New National Album: High Violet

    May is shaping up to be a prime time for festival-ready indie rock with the likes of LCD Soundsystem, Broken Social Scene, Band of Horses, the Black Keys, and the Hold St...

  • Alice In Chains unleash spring tour plans

    Alice In Chains unleash spring tour plans

    Currently in the midst of a late-winter outing that wraps up later this month, resurgent grunge-rock icons Alice In Chains have revealed a spring-tour itinerary as they c...

Have You Read?

  • This week's singles reviewed

    noisettes2.jpgSINGLE OF THE WEEK: NOISETTES SCRATCH YOUR NAME (UNIVERSAL) One of the very few reasons to still believe in indie music, Noisettes provide yet another thrilling single on the back of their debut...
  • SXSW dispatch part one

     Efterklang Once again thousands of indie kids from all around the globe have arrived in Austin, Texas for SXSW, all feeling a sense of smug satisfaction knowing that in years to come they...
  • Guest top 10s: Health

    Our favourite masters of noise HEALTH have come up with their own top 10 of 2009. Feast your eyes after the jump.
  • SXSW10 - first line-up announcement

    It’s subject to change, but SXSW have made the first line up announcement for their 2010 shindig. From a quick glance at the full list below, it seems like it’s the usual mix of up...
  • Violent and Obscene - a tribute to GG Allin

    This sounds pretty awesome - Italian Beach Babes are releasing a 7inch featuring some of the finest bands around playing GG Allin covers. There’s Male Bonding, Fair Ohs, Graffiti Island and...
  • Offset Festival 2009 by Charlie Ingham

    Photo: Charlie Ingham Offset Festival: 2 days in Essex, plenty of bands to see from the unusual No Bra to the headliners The Horrors and everything in-between - Offset has to be the coolest...
  • Bullying at work, and Newsnight on the Archbishop of Canterbury

    PARSLEY'S COMMLOCK Employment Law: Bullying at work Recently I've had cause to help someone with their complaint of bullying in the workplace. I have to say that it has been a very demoralising...
  • Lithuania, and Morrissey on Jonathan Ross

    PARSLEY'S COMMLOCK Country watch : Lithuania Went the furthest I ever have into former Soviet Union countries with a weekend trip to Lithuania for a wedding. I arrived to a snowstorm which I was...

Photos

  • In Pictures: Steve Gullick retrospective

    Legendary rock photographer Steve Gullick has a retrospective at Manchester’s KRAAK Gallery running from March 12th til March 27th, featuring shots taken for NME and Melody Maker as well as his...
  • In Pictures: Tune-Yards, Trash Kit and Think about Life

    To accompany the review of tUnE-yArDs’ Monday gig at Cargo, a few tasty shots of Think about Life, Trash Kit and New England native Merrill Garbus aka tUnE-yArDs. Read the review of the night...
  • In Pictures: Worst Record Covers of the Year

    We have collected some truly heinous examples of recent album covers, from Empire of the Sun’s Star Wars travesty to the banal evil that is Razorlight’s Slipway Fire. Discretionary...
  • In Pictures: Best record covers 2009

    Album art in this gallery was selected based on several simple traits: strong concept, fine graphics including creative typography and general lushness. The first three of ‘The Best Record...
  • In Pictures: Placebo

    Placebo pictures: just in - some photos of Placebo and Brian Molko from last week’s gig at the Glasgow SECC. Also check out the review here

chart

  • the Dirty Dishes - In the Clouds EP

    Ahhhh. I love this. When Jenny Tuite of the Dirty Dishes emailed us at Artrocker.com, there was no extended press drivel or desperate pleadings for promotion, just a simple "Hey there!...
  • Cutting Some Shapes

    Not Squares From: Belfast, Northern Ireland On debut single ‘Asylum’ (Richter Collective) Irish punktronic (we really do love inventing these meaningless genres !) trio Not Squares...
  • Turning Japanese

    The Japanese War Effort From: Scotland, United Kingdom The Japanese War Effort is a one man band, based in Edinburgh. Martin Moog (surely an adopted name otherwise baby he was born to moog...
  • Mondrian, Cakes, Pastries and Mille-Feuille

    There’s a tiny town to the north-east of Paris called Peronne. It’s in the Somme, so it rains a lot, and both the buildings and surrounding countryside are deeply gashed with marks from...
  • Wu Lyf (Finally) and The Great BBC 6Music Sham

    I knew something didn’t add up. The BBC 6Music kerfuffle drags on and on – with more and more music fans, politicians and BBC bigwigs all competing to see who can yelp their opinions the...
  • Sleeping With The NME

    Yes Giantess Boston, Massachusetts, United States The current incarnation of the NME may be a pale shadow of itself and struggling with it’s identity, not knowing whether to...
  • DOWNLOAD: Florence And The Machine - Dog Days Are Over (Breakage Remix)

    Don’t know what angle to go with here. I could talk about how the fact Florence always sounds like a wailing widow means her vocals are perfect for playing the role of anonymous diva to club...
  • EXCLUSIVE NEW DOWNLOAD: Egyptian Hip Hop - Round Pot (This is Horseflesh's Rad Pitt Reincarnation)

    According to This is Horseflesh (the nom de guerre of Egyptian Hip Hop drummer Alex Pierce) this fantastic ‘reincarnation’ of the band’s own "Rad Pitt" was written to...
  • Bromheads: Dedicated mp3

    Bromheads are continuing their free monthly download singles with a genius reworking of ‘Dedicated to the One I Love’, a song made famous by the Shirelles.  Unsubtle mix tape...
  • Japanese Voyeurs new single, track giveaway

    If Wyldman’s recent live review has picqued your interest in Japanese Voyeurs, then you might be interested in their free download track ‘Dumb’.  They’re biffing it out...

Blogs